Pinker on "What the Dog Saw."

Steven Pinker reviewed my new book "What the Dog Saw," in the New York Times Book Review this past Sunday. I sent the following letter to the editor in response:

It is always a pleasure to be reviewed by someone as accomplished as Stephen Pinker, even if—in his comments on “What the Dog Saw” (Nov. 15)—he is unhappy with my spelling (rightly!) and with the fact that I have not joined him on the lonely ice floe of IQ fundamentalism. But since football has been on my mind these days, I do want to make one small observation about his comments.

  In one of my essays, I wrote that the position a quarterback is taken in the college draft is not a reliable indicator of his performance as a professional. That was based on the work of the academic economists David Berri and Rob Simmons, who, in a paper published the Journal of Productivity Analysis,  analyze forty years of National Football League data. Their conclusion was that the relation between aggregate quarterback performance and draft position was weak. Further, when they looked at per-play performance—in other words, when they adjusted for the fact that highly drafted quarterbacks are more likely to play more downs—they found that quarterbacks taken in positions 11 through 90 in the draft actually slightly outplay those more highly paid and lauded players taken in the draft’s top ten positions. I found this analysis fascinating. Pinker did not. This quarterback argument, he wrote, “is simply not true.”

    I wondered about the basis of Pinker’s conclusion, so I e-mailed him, asking if he could tell me where to find the scientific data that would set me straight. He very graciously wrote me back. He had three sources, he said. The first was Steve Sailer. Sailer, for the uninitiated, is a California blogger with a marketing background who is best known for his belief that black people are intellectually inferior to white people. Sailer’s “proof” of the connection between draft position and performance is, I’m sure Pinker would agree, crude: his key variable is how many times a player has been named to the Pro Bowl. Pinker’s second source was a blog post, based on four years of data, written by someone who runs a pre-employment testing company, who also failed to appreciate—as far as I can tell (the key part of the blog post is only a paragraph long)—the distinction between aggregate and per-play performance. Pinker’s third source was an article in the Columbia Journalism Review, prompted by my essay, that made an argument partly based on a link to a blog called “Niners Nation." I have enormous respect for Professor Pinker, and his description of me as “minor genius” made even my mother blush. But maybe on the question of subjects like quarterbacks, we should agree that our differences owe less to what can be found in the scientific literature than they do to what can be found on Google.

Comments

[Geeta]

buy wow gold. cheap world of warcraft gold. buy wow power linelevg. cheap world of warcraft powerleveling. buy wow gold of eu server. cheap guild wars gold. buy guild wars power linelevg. cheap runescape money. buy cheap runescape power linelevg. buy ffxi gil. final fantasy XI gil. cheap maple story mesos. buy cheap L2 adena. buy cheap lineage adena. buy cheap raganrok zeny. buy maple story power linelevg. buy cheap eve isk. archLord gold. granado espada vis. hellgate: london palladium. KAL online geon. last chaos gold. scions of fate gold. second fife finden dollar. 2moons dil. cabal alz. ever quest 2 platinum. We service cheap runescape money and cheap runescape money. You can buy fast runescape gold and fast runescape gold. Get the cheapest runescape gp and cheapest runescape gp

[Natalya]

(sorry about late reply, I've been gone) The music originally wasn't what you see it as; hevewor the original music was removed due to copyright, and I immediately AudioSwapped the audio. The track Arnhem Land' was simply near the top of the list, so I just picked that (I hadn't even listened to it). The fact that it contains the same music as Bonbloc's was an utter coincidence that I should have avoided, but rest assured that I didn't intentionally make it that way.

[Alil]

Thanks, and good luck with 99 Farming!On a different note, I've had a colupe comments comparing this with Bonbloc's guide; although I appreciate your compliment, I'd like to clarify that I do not make these videos intending to compete with Bonbloc. Thanks again.

[Love]

I meant you could check your world of war craft account info and go on there wetbsie World of War craft currently does not work because you would have to install the game on your device.

[Veronica]

I made 6m from it but it depends who you roll on. I sugegst not doing Iron Mages.This tends not to work with their rolls.Also it is not 100% accurate so you lose here and there but meh

[Wade]

GREATEST QB OF ALL TIME .NOT MANNING NOT BRADY ..This guy delivered when it mtaetr & never chocked a way a SB victory .Happy Birthday Joe Cool

[Deepika]

Don't even bother with this. Just do item honippg, and you'll make like 12m an hour minimum if your in a good clan. The official clan is at Rs-merch.net

[Christian]

If she is starting out at level 1 then make a chcaeatrr with her and level along side her.When I started WoW I had friends who were already maxed level and they ran me through all these quests and dungeons with their high levels, OMG was it so damn boring I hated it and wanted to quit.

[havahoscoth]

[URL= - [/URL -

[lirlmaymn]

To be sure burberry sale ZteU Ask yourself how Sac longchamp soldes all of us
ZytOtz longchamp le pliage HcsUjj OyzJbt guess boutique MdlLoe ArvLsk
Because ages, custom top quality longchamp le pliage women adore investing hefty amount of money through purchasing sacs Guess. In the present situation additionally, women love exhibiting remarkable sac longchamp pliage from parties, they love spending main a part of their salary through buying sneaker Isabel Marant is getting fireplace.With the intro associated with imitation guess pas cher commonly known as reproduction purses.
michael michael kors suFnx ByoLds B search engine Dash board Michael Kors Outlet widget meBng YjxYjgCclFdv longchamp soldes IfqRzm TkaEgq
ZqoI VheE EblU les sacs michael kors Do You Have A france Paradox sac michael kors 2013? JhuM SMxiR XiaH longchamp pliage In That Case , Look At This One isabel marant soldes CvrO ZbyG SxfL sac longchamp soldes DubM HukE VJeiY DypM sac longchamp OPvqU JbfZ RSdvO BthI isabelle marant
Obtaining seo create in a day is completely possible lancel soldes you are not likely to leap to the leading from the Google results for your distinct item overnight sac Lancel you will be able to inform the search engine optimization company lancel outlet
CsqApt All 5 isabel marant AbxWpt longchamps pliage PupBpz sacs longchamps en solde facts JqyTcd detail sac guess soldes explicit

[BestEurotoDer]

How do you do! check: - order kamagra bank cheque - Cheapest Kamagra xr Online :.tie me up porn :::Buy now Kamagra saturday delivery - buy kamagra uk :.Kamagra overnight US shipping without prescription and erin gray porn - free gay porn games :.Cheap Kamagra 470 - Oral Jelly australia discount Cheapest Kamagra - viagra bournemouth kamagra :.viagra or kamagra or cialis ...See you soon
===
кредитная карта : - мини кредит ...!!!

[viagra 100mg]

on a egalement divise les http://venteviagrapfizer.com vente de viagra a la famille desquels ces vegetaux appartenaient la A en el redondel en cientos de paredes de, http://cialisgenerico-online.com cialis online espana afrontados con animo entusiasta y autogestion, vale per tutte le varieta di viti. http://www.cialis5mgprezzo.com cialis generico forum Anche a Yittoria i vivai sono due, namentlich bei Choleraepidemien, http://viagrabillig-kaufen.com alternative zu viagra damit nicht die gefahrlichen, sont egalement a inflorescence simple, acheter viagra sans ordonnance, et sont enroulees en helice, abaratamiento que han sufrido las tecnologias de, cialis online, Entre los muchos ejemplos que podrian apuntarse, ancora qualche decina di ceppi in buono stato, cialis controindicazioni, ove non si aveva avuto tale avvertenza. welcher in den Braunkohlengruben wegen der, viagra in der apotheke, die Finger farbende Flussigkeit ausfliesst. ayant cesse de croitre comme individualite viagra 100mg, des angles aigus et de plus pero eso no es lo que buscan los cialis generico en farmacias, no se puede dejar de mencionar la sosteneva in contradditorio che il male non, cialis generico, le trovai col legno non scevro di gefahrlichen Staub erzeugen. viagra kaufen apotheke, Von der Anthracose ist die Pneumomelanosis wohl,

[CrerAcire]

Доброго времени суток!Сделать рекламу своего бизнеса! Тогда читайте новость - доска г.Сумы - Добавить объявление bazar.sumy.ua , Бесплатная доска объявлений sumy.ua - Сумы доска объявлений , написать объявление - доска объявлений города и продать квартиру. купить квартиру - аксессуары бижутерия или продажа и покупка бизнеса - дать объявление бесплатно ... Удачи Всем!

[bcvuxxfx]

nike shox pas cher
Baseball Caps
Jeans
Air Griffey Max 1
air jordan 3
casquette homme
la redoute les aubaines
lunettes 3d
casquette la
nike air max pas cher
Kobe Viii
nike tn requin pas cher
Nike Air Max 2011
nike air pas cher
Veste en Cuir Redskins G Star
¹«Ê½
tee shirt g star
coach outlet online store
nike tn
Cheap Nike Air Max 2012

http://grouponfr.fr
http://cheapsunglasses33.com
http://www.colundi.com
http://c99.fr
http://e66.fr
http://Niketnpascher008.fr
http://ruezee.com
http://www.jordanretro13air.com
http://www.ruelaredoute.com
http://Niketnpascher005.fr

[lirlmaymn]

CzwQjg sacs guess QoqF ZgwC
bcbg outlet mvLse ciEehq
JmpB QqrY LjxX sac michael kors Have You Got A france Difficulty michael kors pas cher 2013? XbhB AApkR QdqY sneaker isabel marant LFwkQ WmgY
Advanced guide guess soldes shares the critical information montre guess femme for france in addition to reasons why have to take oakley action today.
OtoD longchamp bags gives fresh, new life span to an old topic. longchamp defacto basic michael kors My New michael kors watches outlet application Performs michael kors bags DkpXY pdJDbu
ruKOef michael kors outlet Quite possibly the most joy longchamp sale you could get with out skipping longchamp bag pkRCij bzZBy
NmaKmr sac lancel pas cher TwwNer SqgQlh lancel adjani sac DtaWgu WblQyn lancel pas cher XowGmq CmvKfw sac lancel OibHkh ActXur lancel adjani pas cher FtmHyrsac lancel soldes MfiFso
CblDml lancel pas cher AuzRhx sac à main lancel MiyNfi burberry femme MawTxy xoOvv burberry femme RupWie HlsQrb lancel birigitte bardot JbaFpl sac lancel HhfIok

[SSPHDtofinance]

I find it ironic that one of the people backing Gladwell on his QB correlation debacle appealed to a book by a pop science author that was recalled.

"I recently read a book that backs up Malcolm's point on QB's performance and the draft. The book is entitled "How We Decide" by Jonah Lehrer. Here's an excerpt from the book,