A few more thoughts on quarterbacks:
There are two separate issues with respect to quarterbacks. The first is whether, historically, NFL teams have done a good job of predicting which college quarterbacks will succeed in the pros. Dave Berri and Rob Simmons’ paper in the Journal of Productivity Analysis (that I relied on in the essay “Most Likely to Succeed” in my new book “What The Dog Saw”) proves pretty convincingly, I think, that the answer is no. One of the best parts of that paper is how Berri and Simmons demonstrate how much NFL teams tend to irrationally over-weight “combine” variables like speed, height and Wonderlic score.
There’s a second wonderful paper on this general subject by Cade Massey and Richard Thaler—Thaler being, of course, one of the leading lights in behavioral economics—called “The Loser’s Curse.” The argument of the Thaler-Massey paper goes something like this (and I encourage anyone who is interested in sports to read the whole thing, because I can’t do it justice here). By looking at the trades that NFL teams make, we can estimate the “market value” of a draft pick. And what we find is that teams place a very high value on high first round picks. The first pick in the draft, they write, has historically been valued as much as “the 10th and 11th picks combined, and as much as the sum of the last four picks in the first round.” Then Thaler and Massey calculate the true value of draft picks, using what they call “surplus value.” The key here is that all NFL teams operate under a strict salary cap. So a player’s real worth to a team is the extent to which his performance exceeds the average performance of someone making his salary. And what do they find? That market value and surplus value are radically out of sync: that teams irrationally over-weight the importance of high first round picks. In fact, according to their analysis, the most useful draft picks are in the second round, not the first: that’s where surplus values tend to be highest. Hence the title of the paper: “The Loser’s Curse.” The NFL rewards its weakest teams by giving them the highest draft picks—but those picks are actually not the most valuable picks in the draft.
It is important to note here that we are talking about relative value. Personnel decisions in the NFL have clear opportunity costs: if you pay $15 million for a quarterback who only gives you $10 million of value, then you hve $5 million less to pay for a good linebacker. As they write: “To be clear, the player taken with the first pick does have the highest expected performance . . . but he also has the highest salary, and in terms of performance per dollar, is less valuable than players taken in the second round.”
What Massey and Thaler are saying, in essence, is that NFL general managers are not rational decision-makers. That’s why I think its so useful in this particular discussion. Those who believe that draft position is a good predictor of quarterback performance are essentially voting for the good judgment of the people who make draft decisions. And what Berri and Simmons in particular—and Massey and Thaler in general—remind us is that that kind of blind faith in the likes of Matt Millen and Al Davis simply isn’t justified. And, by the way, why should that fallibility come as a surprise? We’ve known for a long time that it is not easy to making decisions under conditions of extreme uncertainty. Here is Massey and Thaler from their conclusion:
Numerous studies find, for example, that physicians, among the most educated professionals in our society, make diagnoses that display overconfidence and violate Bayes’ rule. The point, of course, is that physicians are experts at medicine, not necessarily probabilistic reasoning. And it should not be surprising that when faced with difficult problems, such as inferring the probability that a patient has cancer from a given test, physicians will be prone to the same types of errors that subjects display in the laboratory. Such findings reveal only that physicians are human.
Our modest claim in this paper is that the owners and managers of National Football League teams are also human, and that market forces have not been strong enough to overcome these human failings. The task of picking players, as we have described here, is an extremely difficult one . . . Teams must first make predictions about the future performance of (frequently) immature young men. Then they must make judgments about their own abilities: how much confidence should the team have in its forecasting skills? As we detailed in section 2, human nature conspires to make it extremely difficult to avoid overconfidence in this task.
This brings up the second question. Is it possible to ever accurately predict which college quarterbacks will succeed in the pros? Both the Thaler analysis and the Berri analysis hold out the real possibility that teams can be a lot smarter than they currently are. The New England Patriots clearly have taken some of Thaler’s lessons to heart, for example. There has also been a real effort by the folks over at Pro Football Outsiders to come up with a more useful algorithm for making quarterback selections. David Lewin’s “career forecast” zeroes in on career college starts and career college completion percentage as the best predictors of professional performance. I took the position in my essay “Most Likely to Succeed” that I didn’t think that quarterbacking (as opposed to other positions on the field) was predictable in this sense—that there is so much noise in the data, and so much variability between the college and professional games—that attempts at rationalizing draft day decisions have real limits. I’m still of that inclination. I’m willing to be convinced, though. I’d love to see more statistically-minded people weigh in on the Lewin analysis, and I’d also like to have a better handle over how the recent innovations in college offenses—particularly the use of ever more aggressive spread formations—affects the accuracy of that algorithm.
We're rugby players down here in Australia, so I'm trying to work out the exchange rate. Is it as simple as 2 quarterbacks equal a halfback and 4 quarterbacks equal a fullback?
Posted by: Greg Alder | June 09, 2011 at 01:20 AM
My favorite.I appreciate.
Posted by: Chicago Cubs jerseys | June 15, 2011 at 01:13 AM
thanks for your article,like your blog very much,well done
Posted by: jimmy choo online | July 07, 2011 at 09:08 PM
Thank you! You often write very interesting articles. You improved my mood.I'll be back again.
Posted by: Christian Louboutin Elisabeth Sandals | July 07, 2011 at 10:43 PM
I just desired to remark to display my understanding for a submit because it is especially inviting, and lots of writers do not get the credit score they deserve. I’m constructive I’ll be back again yet again and can deliver a number of of my friends.
Posted by: Office Home and Business 2010 | July 13, 2011 at 10:21 PM
So fun article is! I agree the idea!
Posted by: Coach Factory Store | August 02, 2011 at 05:02 AM
Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts.Definitely this blog is very informative and neatly designed. Really you've motivated me strongly in my new project by this article. I want to tell you that your writing skills are superb.Any way Ill be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.
http://websiteandtraffic.blogspot.com
http://howtowebsitetraffic.blogspot.com
http://bestweightlossdietsthatwork.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchstore.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchmarket.blogspot.com
Posted by: Peoplesearch2u | August 25, 2011 at 11:37 AM
Ralph Lauren is the leader of worldwide popular brands without doubt, Ralph Lauren Outlet offers comfortable and fashionable clothing both for men and women. Buy Ralph Lauren Outlet Online and enjoy the beauty, fashion yet comfort!
Posted by: Polo Outlet | September 07, 2011 at 04:00 AM
It is my great pleasure to visit your website and to enjoy your excellent post here. I like that very much. I can feel that you paid much attention for those articles, as all of them make sense and are very useful. Thanks so much for sharing.
http://websiteandtraffic.blogspot.com
http://howtowebsitetraffic.blogspot.com
http://bestweightlossdietsthatwork.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchstore.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchmarket.blogspot.com
Posted by: Peoplesearch2u | September 08, 2011 at 05:14 PM
Great post. Really helped me. Thankyou.
http://websiteandtraffic.blogspot.com
http://howtowebsitetraffic.blogspot.com
http://bestweightlossdietsthatwork.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchstore.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchmarket.blogspot.com
Posted by: Peoplesearch2u | September 08, 2011 at 05:28 PM
It is my great pleasure to visit your website and to enjoy your excellent post here. I like that very much. I can feel that you paid much attention for those articles, as all of them make sense and are very useful. Thanks so much for sharing.
http://websiteandtraffic.blogspot.com
http://howtowebsitetraffic.blogspot.com
http://bestweightlossdietsthatwork.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchstore.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchmarket.blogspot.com
Posted by: Peoplesearch2u | September 08, 2011 at 05:47 PM
It is my great pleasure to visit your website and to enjoy your excellent post here. I like that very much. I can feel that you paid much attention for those articles, as all of them make sense and are very useful. Thanks so much for sharing.
http://websiteandtraffic.blogspot.com
http://howtowebsitetraffic.blogspot.com
http://bestweightlossdietsthatwork.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchstore.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchmarket.blogspot.com
Posted by: Peoplesearch2u | September 08, 2011 at 05:52 PM
It is my great pleasure to visit your website and to enjoy your excellent post here. I like that very much. I can feel that you paid much attention for those articles, as all of them make sense and are very useful. Thanks so much for sharing.
http://websiteandtraffic.blogspot.com
http://howtowebsitetraffic.blogspot.com
http://bestweightlossdietsthatwork.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchstore.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchmarket.blogspot.com
Posted by: Peoplesearch2u | September 08, 2011 at 05:53 PM
Hi,
This Is Good Articles,I See And I like This Articles.So Nice.
http://websiteandtraffic.blogspot.com
http://howtowebsitetraffic.blogspot.com
http://bestweightlossdietsthatwork.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchstore.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchmarket.blogspot.com
Posted by: Peoplesearch2u | September 08, 2011 at 07:01 PM
Your articles are such joy to read.
http://peoplesearchmarket.blogspot.com
http://websiteandtraffic.blogspot.com
http://howtowebsitetraffic.blogspot.com
http://bestweightlossdietsthatwork.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchstore.blogspot.com/
Posted by: Peoplesearch2u | September 15, 2011 at 02:25 AM
Your articles are such joy to read.
http://peoplesearchmarket.blogspot.com
http://websiteandtraffic.blogspot.com
http://howtowebsitetraffic.blogspot.com
http://bestweightlossdietsthatwork.blogspot.com/
http://peoplesearchstore.blogspot.com/
Posted by: Peoplesearch2u | September 15, 2011 at 02:29 AM
How are you going those days? I am your sincere follower. Thanks for your informative articles. Reading them makes my surfing on the internet become more meaningful and interesting.
Posted by: Hogan sito ufficiale | September 23, 2011 at 05:14 AM
In last weeks Economist, there's a semi-decent article on reading sentiment from large masses of anecdotal data (tweets, mainly).
Posted by: louboutin schaussures | September 27, 2011 at 04:17 PM
I think that getting better players per dollar is not as important then the salary cap in the NFL. Take Tom Brady for example; He was a back up player for Adam Viniteri but when Adam got injured, Tom Brady came in and won 3 super bowls.
Posted by: Greg Martin | October 07, 2011 at 12:19 PM
I like the writing structure of your blog and it does a pretty decent job of presenting the material.
Posted by: Mulberry Purses Outlet | October 14, 2011 at 05:17 AM
バーバリーマフラー
北海道由仁町内の診療所で国が注射器の使い回しを放置したためC型肝炎ウイルス感染が多発したとして、バーバリーハンドバッグ
同町の住民らが来年1月にも、国に1人300万円の慰謝料を求めて札幌地裁に提訴する。提訴予定者は既に100人を超えており、7日に弁護団が結成された。弁護団によると、バーバリー アウトレットC型肝炎感染者の割合が高い地域は国内に同町を含め約50カ所あるとされ、こうした「地域偏在」を根拠に訴訟を起こすのは全国初という。
バーバリーマフラー訴えるのは、町内にあった2カ所の診療所で治療を受けたことがある患者や遺族。バーバリー財布多くは50~80年代ごろに「ホット注射」と呼ばれる解熱剤の投与を受けていた。原告側は「どちらの診療所も注射器を水洗いしただけで使い回していた」と指摘。
バーバリー アウトレット世界保健機関(WHO)は53年に注射器を煮沸消毒するよう警告を出したが、国はその後も適切な指導を怠ったと主張している。
Posted by: バーバリーマフラー | November 07, 2011 at 08:13 PM
バーバリーマフラー
2診療所は84年までに閉院しカルテなどは残っていないが、疫学データのほか、専門家や患者、家族らの証言から感染原因を証明する方針だ。バーバリーハンドバッグ
道健康づくり財団の調査では、由仁町では09年までの10年間で62人が肝がんで死亡、死亡率が全国平均の2.44倍に上る。
バーバリー アウトレット国内の肝がんによる死者の7~8割はC型肝炎ウイルス感染者とされ、弁護団の西村武彦弁護士は「使い回しを放置した国の不正をただし、
バーバリーマフラー医療費助成の拡大などにつなげたい」と話す。
バーバリー財布注射器の使い回しを巡っては6月に和解基本合意したB型肝炎訴訟で国の責任が明記されているが、C型肝炎は対象になっていない。
バーバリー アウトレットまた08年に救済法が成立した薬害C型肝炎訴訟は、感染原因を血液製剤投与に限定している。
Posted by: バーバリーマフラー | November 07, 2011 at 08:17 PM
It's good to see this information in your article.
Posted by: north face | November 23, 2011 at 03:46 AM
ティンバーランドDeNAが元横浜監督の山下大輔氏(59)に二軍監督への就任を要請したことが13日、わかった。
ティンバーランド山下氏は同日、都内で取材に応じ、「まだ返事はしていないが、前向きには考えている」と語った。山下氏は1974年にドラフト1位で大洋(現DeNA)に入団。88年に引退後、ヘッドコーチなどを経て、2003、04年に横浜(現DeNA)の監督を務めた。
Posted by: ティンバーランド | December 14, 2011 at 12:40 AM
ティンバーランド森、山田両氏はこれまでの特捜部の任意聴取に対し、損失隠しへの関与を認めた上で、菊川氏へも逐一報告していたことに言及。菊川氏は三者委に「損失隠しは知っていたが、額については最近知った」と証言しており、特捜部は近く菊川氏からも事情聴取する。
ティンバーランド監視委は刑事処分とは別に、同社が4社買収による資金捻出で損失処理を終えていることから、行政処分である課徴金を科すよう金融庁に勧告する見通しだ。
Posted by: ティンバーランド | December 14, 2011 at 12:48 AM